Skip to main content

A Depressing Look at Government Spending

 As a fun little exercise I thought I’d sit down and calculate government spending per person. The only difference is that I wanted to get everything. Often politicians talk about operating budgets and the deficits on that, but that isn’t the whole picture. There are capital budgets too.

Government is paid for by the taxpayers, so everything on the table. I did this for a person living in the City of Calgary, in the province of Alberta and obviously living in Canada. These numbers absolutely shocked me beyond recognition. It illustrates a spending problem that is far beyond our control. People act like raising taxes a little more will solve these issues, they won’t.

These numbers are presented informally. I’m not going to source each budgetary page, as I wanted to get the broad numbers. Some of these numbers are the estimated costs rather than the actual costs for the fiscal period of 2019. You can look up these values yourself and they may vary slightly, but don’t take away from the staggering end result.

I realize some would argue that capital budgets are for one time purchases, true enough, but when capital budgets are developed over periods of 3-5 years, are always there and never small – they are a systemic part of the cost of government. It’s not like billions are spent one year and the next 10 years is a small capital budget. There are always large capital budgets. I also want to know that some capital buildings produce some revenue. Most hospitals will have a coffee shop and convenience store tenants that pay rent. A skate park doesn’t result in any revenue. Taking a look at some of the numbers, it seems like revenue generated from capital projects will be in the range of 10-15% of the capital budget.

Calgary

ITEM
Capital Budget 2019-2023 (5 years – $5.3 billion)$1.06 billion/year
Operating Budget 2019-2022 (4 years – $17.2 billion + 92.9 million one time)$4.32 billion/year
Estimated Population1,560,600
Total Cost$5.38 billion/year
Cost per Person$3447.40

Alberta

ITEM
Capital Budget (3 years – $19.3 billion)$6.43 billion/year
Operating Budget 2019$58.720 billion
Estimated Population4,428,427
Total Cost$65.15 billion/year
Cost per Person$14,711.77

Canada

ITEM
Operating Budget 2019$346.182 billion
Estimated Population37,000,000
Cost per Person$9356.27

Total

TOTAL PER PERSON (ALL SPENDING)$27,515.44 PER YEAR

This is a devastating number to see. If you live in a city in Canada, this is roughly the government spending. Government money comes from taxpayers, so this is the expected obligations of taxpayers. This number I’ve calculated is for each person that exists in the country, province and city. Not everyone works and pays taxes, so the number is more crippling and awful than shown. At the end of the day, how could anyone pay this much, every single year? It’s not like you can “get the rich” or “tax businesses” as if that solves the crippling aspect of the number. The economics have been settled on soaking the rich and it doesn’t work.

This depresses me. Solving this problem is next to impossible with the state of the world and the irrationality of the average person. Plus the added demands of more and more spending demands. Even if we were to get all governments to cut spending in half, it’s still a ridiculous number.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Island of Bryan Solar Panel Numbers are Horribly Misleading

Who doesn't want to be all sustainable and oh so environmentally friendly? I was watching the show and they brought down their 'friend' to help them get some solar panels on their resort. By friend, they mean some strategic business partnership to advertise the business, but that's not what I'm here to talk about - even though if this was an oil company 'friend' then all the numbers would be instantly scrutinized by default. Not in this case. And it just annoys me at how sloppy, misleading and downright fraudulent the way the solar crew present numbers. Here's how things were presented on the show: This is an island in the Bahamas which uses a diesel generator for electricity.  Diesel is dirty. The cost of this electricity is 35 cents/kWh. Solar is only 5 cents/kWh. Solar is obviously clean. Pays itself back in three years. When things are presented like this it only make sense to do solar right? It's drastically cheaper. It's cleaner. It's j

The West is Weak: Russia Invades Ukraine

 I haven't been writing a lot lately on this blog, but I felt the need to sign in and write about this. I've found myself feeling a bit depressed about the invasion of Ukraine - not because it happened, but due to how the west will predictably react to it. There will be a lot of talk, strong words, and even stronger rhetoric, but when the actual words become policy - it will be pathetically weak. There are people out there that seem to think or at least try to force the narrative of a simple dichotomy: either we accept Putin is doing it or it's WW3. Any normal person would find the choices here to be nauseating either way. If history is to serve a lesson, the first option often leads to the second option. But this dichotomy really illustrates the parameter that most people don't pick up on. The West is Morally Weak The facts are on the ground. The United States has the largest armed forces in human existence. A coalition of western powers is devastatingly more powerful

Milquetoast Brian Jean

  I've been following the UCP leader campaign here in Alberta with great interest. There has been a very anti-Kenney sentiment in the air around here, in particular with Kenney's top down party style, the lack of pushing back at Ottawa and over COVID restrictions/vaccine passports.  Brian Jean lost to Kenney and it looks like he lost because he was politically outmaneuvered - rather than a battle of ideas. He's obviously sour and was on the anti-Kenney train ever since. Let's just say that I was a bit excited that he's back. I wanted to see what he had to prove and that he may have some fire in him. The problem I have had with conservatives as of late is them being milquetoast. All that means is that they're very safe, very center and literally bring nothing to the table. Even though conservatives in CANADA say there are many things that need to change, they don't actually do anything all that different than the governing left. Maybe not as bad, but it all s